Marinwood CSD general manager Eric Dreikosen reports hiring an architect for $12,000 for all inclusive price for a maintenance shed proposal but fails to reveal that it is former Marinwood CSD director, Bill Hansell . Dreikosen was hired by the CSD board that included Bill Hansell in 2015 . The total budget cost of the project has not been revealed and the architects fees have exceeded the $12,000 before reaching site plan approval stage. Another architect with decades of experience with public works projects, bid $13,800 for the ENTIRE PROJECT including site plan review (fixed price $2800), construction oversight and architects fee of 8% based on $100,000 construction cost. He lost the bid. The CSD has attacked critics as spreading "misinformation" yet hides its plans and budgets. You be the judge how well they handle the public's business. This clip is from the February 13, 2018 Marinwood CSD board meeting.
Tuesday, May 11, 2021
At the Jan 27, 2020 Marin Planning Commission meeting, commissioner asks about the public outreach. Jeff Naylor's famous response in September 2018 to a petition of 200 residents tells the real story of "public outreach" Still there has been no meeting. The project budget is secret and the architect, a former CSD politician has estimated billing 500% of the initial estimates BEFORE the plan has been approved. Hansell Design has a highly unusual "unlimited billing" fee arrangement with NO PERFORMANCE provisions. While CSD Director, Bill Hansell hired current manager Eric Dreikosen at double his previous compensation despite NO EXPERIENCE in managing a CSD. This is small town corruption on display enabled by the entire CSD board.
The Multimillion Dollar Shed is Missing Area for Loading/Unloading Landscaping Materials and Vehicle Movement.
The proposed Marinwood Maintenance Compound won't have a grassy area in front.
This area must be used for loading/unloading of landscape materials.
The Marinwood CSD maintenance crew generates big piles of landscaping debris and trash each week. They store this in the large open area next to the horse shoe pits in Marinwood Park to allow the convenient loading/dumping of material.
|Large piles of landscaping waste and trash is stored in the open at the Maintenance shed|
A bucket loading operation requires much space as you can see in this video. Generally, the dump trailer is loaded from the side into the center of the trailer. The operator must do this to balance the load for safety. This means the bucket loader requires a large area for scooping material and turning.
The truck and trailer must be parked perpendicular to the bucket loader.
In the site plan of the proposed Maintenance Facility below, you can see that the only area where this operation can take place is IN FRONT of the Maintenance Facility. The architect has drawn a walking path in this area to deceive the planning department. There is NO ROOM inside the walled maintenance compound to perform a mechanized loading operation.
Our Ford F250 is 22 feet long.and the dump trailer is approximately 20 feet long including tongue.
This means that 42 feet of space will be required for the truck/trailer and an additional 40' to 60' feet to the side will be required for the bucket loader and material. This will occupy all the area between the maintenance building and Miller Creek.
|Proposed Maintenance Facility with old facility overlay in brown|
This drawing shows the footprint of the proposed Maintenance Bldg and the old building footprint in brown. The brown box on the left is the area the architect calls open storage. In fact the entire area from the current building to the horse shoe pit is used for landscaping debris, parking and tool storage. Clearly there is no area suitable for loading and unloading material within the proposed Maintenance Building above. The architect shows this area as green space and a walking path but it will not happen. It will be used for parking and storage of debris and landscaping materials. The is no alternative.
What happened to the access road that the architect showed in previous drawings? It has disappeared. This is highly deceptive. The architect must show where essential activities will take place on the building site. Safety vehicles and pedestrians must pass through this area.
The drawings do not show the true impact to the stream conservation area and Marinwood Park.
The proposed Marinwood CSD Maintenance Facility is simply too big and inefficient, harms the environment and occupies land that should be used for recreational purposes as intended.
The Marinwood "Drive Through" Maintenance Facility now before the Marin County Planning board is completely unworkable for the maintenance department and our service vehicles. The video below shows why. Our maintenance department has a 2018 Ford F250 truck that is 22 feet long and a 16' dump trailer. Just like the truck in the short video, our F250 needs 51.9 feet to turn around .
This means that our truck will be on the edge of Miller Creek stream bank every time it needs to turn around, rain or shine. More likely it will drive to the meadow to turn around and destroy this lovely area too.
In 2007, a catastrophic flood destroyed the stream bank below the current maintenance facility to prevent it from being lost. If you look at the eastern edge of the maintenance shed, you will see the edge of the stream bank.
While the proposed maintenance facility is further away from the current garage area, it is still far too close to the stream bank where flooding occurs. It is COMPLETELY within the restricted area under the 2007 Stream Conservation Ordinance.
This would be bad news for the CSD but fortunately, Irv Schwartz, noted Marin Civil Engineer and former CSD Director came up with the best solution in 2017 called "Option 3". It is a conventional maintenance facility design that is long and narrow and is situated next to the fence line. It is the same size as the McInnis Park facility or about ONE THIRD the size and cost of the proposed Marinwood Park facility.
|Option #3 is the "environmentally preferred" option for our next maintenance facility.|
Tell the Marinwood CSD/ Marin County to stop wasting money on a maintenance compound that will destroy our park. Design a new facility based on Option Three.