A blog about Marinwood-Lucas Valley and the Marin Housing Element, politics, economics and social policy. The MOST DANGEROUS BLOG in Marinwood-Lucas Valley.
Showing posts with label Andy Hyman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andy Hyman. Show all posts
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
VIDEO: Bridge Housing "We have given Dixie Schools an estimate of 1.8 students per apartment" (150 students)
On October 27, 2012 Bridge Housing VP, Brad Wilban explains to skeptical residents how many school children he expects in the Dixie school districts.
Here is the transcript:
Brad Wilban (BW): "I think a month from now, when we come back, we're going to tell you exactly what we are going to do."
Audience (A): "When you come back, can you tell us about the impact on our schools?"
BW: (Surprised puts up his hand in Stop gesture and looks away to address the other side of the room). "We have given Dixie our projections of what we expect the school impacts to be (motions a sweeping gesture) from toddlers to high school."
"We have a large universe (round gesture) of our properties will similar demographics and so we know that about 1.8 students per unit on average is generated from this kind of housing"
Whole audience: (gasps )
A: "Wow, that's 160 kids, 150 kids!"
BW: (Gesture "stop") "So that's infants through high school so next month when we come, we will bring a break down, zero through five, elementary, middle school and high school. Not what we know will happen but what we think will happen based on our experience and that way, you can say 30 kids in high school and there is going to be 20 kids in middle school or what ever it is. So we will come back with that (pointing gesture)"
=======================================
Editor's note: We note that 30 kids in high school and 20 kids in middle school will leave 100 kids for the elementary school. We believe, Mr Wilban realizing the controversial nature of school impacts intentionally changed his remarks mid sentence. The following month, he offered an unbelievable estimate of .8 children per household to give the appearance of a minor impact on our schools. This is not a credible estimate and easily can be disproven with actual enrollment statistics from family affordable housing complexes available from San Rafael and neighboring school districts.
I doubt there is a family affordable housing complex in Marin that has .8 children per household anywhere. When the city of Pleasanton, projected 1.2 children per house hold, they had a rude awakening when 3.1 children per household arrived and they had to build new schools. It is highly likely that local taxpayers will be forced to adapt new parcel taxes and bond issues to accommodate the Marinwood Village proposal as it is currently presented.
We can consider senior affordable housing in Marinwood-Lucas Valley but SHOULD NOT ALLOW ANY FAMILY SUBSIDIZED HOUSING that does not have strong financial support for the education of the children who will be coming into our community. This support could come from a commercial project such as the Farm to Table market which will generate millions in sales taxes or it could come from the non profit developers themselves who may provide realistic financial support for our schools.
We hope that Bridge housing will not force their unsustainable plans on our community without providing for it's tenants and the community that will host them.
We are asking our school board and administrators for unbiased student enrollment data from the San Rafael and neighboring school districts from affordable housing complexes owned by Bridge Housing and EAH Housing.
The community has a right to know of the full impacts of "non profit" subsidized housing projects before they are approved.
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Dixie School District is forced to PAY THE STATE for educating our children.
Editors Note: I could not believe it when I saw this piece in the San Rafael Patch . Dixie school district actually must PAY THE STATE for each student. Marinwood Village is estimated to bring in 150 children and we will pay the state $22,050 yearly if I understand this correctly. Clearly the Marinwood Village Proposal cannot be approved under the current funding scheme.
Is Gov. Brown Right to Dole Out Money to Marin's Public Schools Unequally?
Compare per-student funding for Marin County schools. You may be surprised.
This is what California public education looks like after the Great Recession:
Between 2007 and 2010, the number of teachers in the state's K-12 classrooms shrunk by 11 percent. Reading specialists, librarians, and other school employees helping students learn declined by 14 percent. Front offices took the hardest blow, with the number of administrators dropping by 16 percent. All these cuts hit schools even as the total enrollment held steady at around 6.2 million students.
Now that California is looking at its first budget without a deficit in five years, Gov. Jerry Brown's budget calls for restoring some money to the state's public schools. But, he does not want to distribute the money equally.
[For differences in revenues between Marin County school districts during the 2010-11 school year, see the tables at the bottom of this article.]
"Aristotle said, 'Treating unequals equally is not justice.' And people are in different situations. Growing up in Compton or Richmond is not like it is to grow up in Los Gatos or Beverly Hills or Piedmont," Brown said, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
There are already big differences in the sums school districts get from the state.
Consider two very different communities in Marin, Mill Valley and Novato. In
the 2010-11 school year, the Mill Valley School District received $10,895 for every student. The Novato Unified School District received $8,575 per student.
But while $3,908 of Novato's per-student funding came from the state, Mill Valley received negative-$25 per student due to so-called state "take-backs." That’s largely because of the different revenue structures for those two districts. As a basic aid district, Mill Valley receives the lion's share of its revenue, or $5,604 per student, from local property taxes. It also receive $4,443 per student from its annual parcel tax, which was increased by voters in the November 2012 election.
By contrast, Novato is a revenue limit district, receiving nearly half of its revenue from the state.
Under Gov. Brown's proposed budget, which has $3 billion more than last year for K-12 and community colleges, underprivileged schools would get more per-student funding than other schools. That means that funding would be weighted towards those schools with higher percentages of English language learners and the number of students who receive federally subsidized lunches for low-income residents, according to Marin County Office of Education officials.
The differences in those areas within Marin are stark.
For instance, while the Ross Valley Elementary School District recorded 3.1 percent English Learners in the 2009-2010, the San Rafael City Elementary District recorded 51.5 percent English Learners.
"Our future depends not on across-the-board funding, but disproportionately funding those schools that have disproportionate challenges," Brown said in a press conference last week.
Will Gov. Brown's proposed shift in funding be enough to bridge the economic gap that contributes to the achievement gap? Does more money improve student performance?
Source: California Department of Education, Ed-Data
Between 2007 and 2010, the number of teachers in the state's K-12 classrooms shrunk by 11 percent. Reading specialists, librarians, and other school employees helping students learn declined by 14 percent. Front offices took the hardest blow, with the number of administrators dropping by 16 percent. All these cuts hit schools even as the total enrollment held steady at around 6.2 million students.
Now that California is looking at its first budget without a deficit in five years, Gov. Jerry Brown's budget calls for restoring some money to the state's public schools. But, he does not want to distribute the money equally.
[For differences in revenues between Marin County school districts during the 2010-11 school year, see the tables at the bottom of this article.]
"Aristotle said, 'Treating unequals equally is not justice.' And people are in different situations. Growing up in Compton or Richmond is not like it is to grow up in Los Gatos or Beverly Hills or Piedmont," Brown said, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
There are already big differences in the sums school districts get from the state.
Consider two very different communities in Marin, Mill Valley and Novato. In
the 2010-11 school year, the Mill Valley School District received $10,895 for every student. The Novato Unified School District received $8,575 per student.
But while $3,908 of Novato's per-student funding came from the state, Mill Valley received negative-$25 per student due to so-called state "take-backs." That’s largely because of the different revenue structures for those two districts. As a basic aid district, Mill Valley receives the lion's share of its revenue, or $5,604 per student, from local property taxes. It also receive $4,443 per student from its annual parcel tax, which was increased by voters in the November 2012 election.
By contrast, Novato is a revenue limit district, receiving nearly half of its revenue from the state.
Under Gov. Brown's proposed budget, which has $3 billion more than last year for K-12 and community colleges, underprivileged schools would get more per-student funding than other schools. That means that funding would be weighted towards those schools with higher percentages of English language learners and the number of students who receive federally subsidized lunches for low-income residents, according to Marin County Office of Education officials.
The differences in those areas within Marin are stark.
For instance, while the Ross Valley Elementary School District recorded 3.1 percent English Learners in the 2009-2010, the San Rafael City Elementary District recorded 51.5 percent English Learners.
"Our future depends not on across-the-board funding, but disproportionately funding those schools that have disproportionate challenges," Brown said in a press conference last week.
Will Gov. Brown's proposed shift in funding be enough to bridge the economic gap that contributes to the achievement gap? Does more money improve student performance?
| Dixie (San Rafael) Elementary SD Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for elementary school districts |
| State Aid | -$147 | 0% |
| Local Property Taxes | $6,273 | 317% |
| Federal Revenue | $373 | 40% |
| Other State Revenue | $801 | 54% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $2,100 | 286% |
| Total | $9,400 | 111% |
| Mill Valley Elementary School District Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for elementary school districts |
| State Aid | -$25 | 0% |
| Local Property Taxes | $5,604 | 283% |
| Federal Revenue | $316 | 34% |
| Other State Revenue | $556 | 38% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $4,443 | 605% |
| Total | $10,895 | 129% |
| Novato USD Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for unified school districts |
| State Aid | $3,908 | 114% |
| Local Property Taxes | $1,378 | 71% |
| Federal Revenue | $550 | 49% |
| Other State Revenue | $1,187 | 60% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $1,552 | 292% |
| Total | $8,575 | 95% |
| Ross Valley Elementary SD Revenue for 2010-2011 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for elementary school district |
| State Aid | $3,672 | 110% |
| Local Property Taxes | $1,539 | 78% |
| Federal Revenue | $287 | 31% |
| Other State Revenue | $965 | 65% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $2,197 | 299% |
| Total | $8,660 | 102% |
| San Rafael City Elementary SD Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for elementary school districts |
| State Aid | $3,474 | 104% |
| Local Property Taxes | $1,594 | 81% |
| Federal Revenue | $894 | 96% |
| Other State Revenue | $1,660 | 112% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $1,665 | 227% |
| Total | $9,286 | 110% |
| San Rafael City High School District Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for high school districts |
| State Aid | $60 | 2% |
| Local Property Taxes | $9,702 | 308% |
| Federal Revenue | $578 | 65% |
| Other State Revenue | $370 | 25% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $2,092 | 295% |
| Total | $12,802 | 131% |
| Tamalpais Union High SD Revenue for 2010-11 | ||
| Source | $ Amount per student | % Statewide average for high school districts |
| State Aid | -$69 | 0% |
| Local Property Taxes | $11,792 | 374% |
| Federal Revenue | $395 | 44% |
| Other State Revenue | $529 | 35% |
| Other Local Revenue (includes parcel taxes) | $3,595 | 507% |
| Total | $16,241 | 167% |
Friday, March 29, 2013
"Our Budget is Unsustainable" says Dixie Board President Andy Hyman in 2011
Editor's Note: Andy Hyman has held elective office on the Dixie School Board since 2002. He currently serves as president and represents the public oversight of the the Dixie schools. The Dixie School system is facing huge costs from affordable housing developments like Marinwood Village.
In addition to the costs of possible relocation of the Dixie school bus yard next to the Dixie School district will need 3-7 portable classrooms at $150,000 each plus teachers, books, computers and support staff for the added school population. The cost is in the millions of dollars. At the 3/28/2013 Marinwood Association meeting, he explained that additional school funding was being sought by Susan Adams from various sources including capital funds and grants from the Marin Community Foundation.
Since the publication of this article in 2011, school enrollments have increase by at least 80 students and the budgets have been cut an additional $340,000 and further reduced in the latest budget cycle.
On December 11, 2012, Superintendent Thomas Lohwasser writes
"Dixie School District has also been impacted by the state budget crisis with state funding cuts and with the Basic Aid Fair Share. Since 2009-10 we have been cut over $3.2 million in state funding, with expected future cuts of $1.1 annually. Revenues have been stagnant and for 2011-12 were below the level of funding we received in 2007-08. Within the same period of time expenditures have increased over $300,000."
see Dr. Lohwasser's 2012 Dixie School Budget Memo
Clearly, we have a funding crisis now. It will only get many times worse with Marinwood Village which is estimated to bring 150 children to our schools without any tax base to support them.
The Dixie School Board must address the community and provide analysis and advice. As of March 11, 2013 the Planning Commission has not heard an official statement from Mr Hyman or the Dixie School Board on school impacts of a massive student population increase from six large affordable housing projects without supporting tax revenue.
Budget, curriculum emphasized in Dixie school board race
Navigating a difficult financial climate and maintaining a
high quality of education have been named as priorities by all three candidates
for the board in North San Rafael's Dixie School District.
Like other districts, the Dixie district has been squeezed by the economic downturn. In the past three years it has been forced to make staff reductions and furloughs, freeze salaries and cancel summer school to help make up for millions of dollars in lost funding.
In May, voters approved a parcel tax hike of $107 — the total tax is now $352 — with an overwhelming 80 percent majority, but more difficult times are expected.
Andy Hyman, the school board's current president, said the board will have to consider cuts and should look to non-classroom items first, such as the district's practice of owning and operating its own school bus system.
"Our budget as it stands is unsustainable going forward," Hyman said.
McDaniel said she would want to explore potential revenue sources, such as leases on unused district real estate.
"Impacting the classrooms and the teachers' salaries would be one of the last things that I would recommend doing," McDaniel said.
Vuillermet said she would want to learn more about the budget and seek input from teachers,
parents, administrators and other board members before identifying budget fixes.
"Most of the budget you don't have any flexibility with," Vuillermet said. "The important thing is to focus on the 20 or 30 percent that we have some control over."
On the issue of instruction, the three candidates said they would seek to balance core subjects that are the focus of standardized tests, such as math and English, with other subjects such as music and art.
Vuillermet said the emphasis should be on core subjects.
"In order to be marketable for when these kids hit the job market, I think these kids need to have the basics down very well, they need to have math, science, reading, writing," Vuillermet said. "All of those are very critical, and I think those need to be the focus. That being said, I think you do need to educate the whole child."
McDaniel said she has mixed feelings about standardized tests, and supports exploring options such as moving standardized tests to the beginning of the school year to help teachers focus on material other than what is covered by tests.
"Right now our teachers are doing a fantastic job with the curriculum," she said.
Hyman said non-core subjects and education that target students' emotional and social development should have a prominent place in the curriculum.
"A math or an English language test doesn't get at educating the whole child," Hyman said. "We're proud of the test scores, but it doesn't tell the whole picture."
Contact Will Jason via email at wjason@marinij.com
Andrew Hyman
Age: 61
Occupation: Direct sales manager, Toyota
Marin
Education: Bachelor's degree in social science
1973, San Francisco State University; teaching credential, 1977, California
State University, Hayward, 1977
Experience: Dixie school board trustee and
current president; former teacher; Dixie Home and School Association board
member; Marin County School Boards Association president; Youth Leadership
Institute board member; Marin County Schools Joint Legislative Advisory
Committee member; Dixie School District Advisory Team member; Dixie
Multi-Purpose Building Fundraising Committee co-chair; Dixie School District
Green Initiative Team member; Dixie Home to School Transportation Marketing
Committee chair
lll
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
